How a reviewer scores wine depends on a variety of factors. These can include a person’s experience, how they approach scoring wines, what scoring system them use, how they use that system, and other considerations. Here I explain how I think about high scoring wines, specifically wines that receive scores of 95 points and above.
To me, 95+ points are “classic” wines. These are wines that could be put alongside the very best wines in the world from their best vintages and sit there comfortably. (See my scoring system at Northwest WIne Report.)
To accomplish this, there usually needs to be an alignment of factors. These includes a top quality site, exceptional farming, a high quality vintage, and superb winemaking that appropriately maximizes each of these factors to the winery’s style.
Aligning all of these factors is exceedingly difficult. Why? There is always vintage variation. Annual growing conditions favor certain sites, varieties, producers, and styles over others.
Now, if one is starting with a higher quality site, better farming, and exceptional winemaking, the floor is higher. However, it doesn’t necessarily mean that the ceiling is higher.
The ceiling is dictated by vintage conditions. It also depends on how well those conditions fit a producer’s style, farming, and site as well as how well the producer maximizes what they are given.
To me, all of these factors aligning to create extremely high quality wines is exceedingly rare. This is true not just here in the Pacific Northwest but in the wider wine world. How rare?
Looking at nearly 16,000 wines I’ve reviewed using the 100-point system, I’ve given a tiny percentage scores of 95+ points. How tiny? 1.3%. I have given a total of 253 wines scores of 95+ points ever.
How does this align with other review outlets? It aligns well with some; it does not align well with others.
Let’s compare Wine Spectator, which also tastes wines blind, as I do. Out of nearly 30,000 Northwest wine reviews, the publication has given – wait for it – 1.3% of wines ratings of 95+ points (399 wines out of 29,921).
Personally, I don’t find that concurrence with the percentage in my reviews surprising. First, again, I taste and review wines blind, as Wine Spectator does. Second, I was a religious follower of Wine Spectator’s scores for Northwest wines back when I first started tasting and rating wine. In fact, the concordance of my reviews with Harvey Steiman’s when he was at the publication was one of the things that gave me early confidence. It’s not an exaggeration to say that I learned wine scoring from Harvey Steiman. Moreover, I expect that Wine Spectator‘s reviewers and I think about 95+ point wines in a similar way
What does the percentage of 95+ point wines look like at some other review outlets? It can be as much as 20-25% of wines reviewed. That is a staggering difference!
What accounts for this? I believe there are four reasons.
First, blind tasting takes away what I call “prestige points.” These don’t affect every wine a reviewer tastes, but they can heavily affect some wines.
Second, when blind tasting, one needs to be wholly convinced by what’s in the glass. That makes the bar that much higher to clear.
Third, a reviewer’s perspective on scoring makes a substantial difference. For some reviewers, 95+ is simply a really good bottle of wine. To me, these are profound wines, not just the best wines produced in that vintage but among the best wines produced ever.
Finally, score inflation has surely played a role. I hate to say it, but 95 is the new 90 at some outlets.
To me, 95+ point wines are the vinous equivalent to multi-planetary alignments. They happen, just not all that often for reasons I’ve described above.
I’m not saying that the way I think about this is right. It’s just the way that I see things and how I approach scoring. On my tasting table, 95+ wines remain the exception. They are not the rule. I am always open to letting the wines convince me otherwise.
To receive email notifications about new articles, CLICK HERE.
The Northwest Wine Report Fall Subscriber Drive has started! If you’re not already a subscriber, please consider subscribing now. It’s the only way that this site will be able to continue publishing in 2027. See the number of new subscribers still needed on the top right of the site. Click on the button below to subscribe.

Leave A Comment